Don’t Shoot the Messenger!

When I was home recently I found there was a lot of confusion about the timber supply and job loss numbers I had commented on in the press. Some people were more angry than confused, some were angry at me.

Let me try to clear up some of the confusion and address people’s anger.

First, the numbers are not mine. The timber supply documents released to the public come from internal government assessments of the state of our pine beetle ravaged forests. The documents clearly indicate that all the companies operating in our area played a major role in this analysis and that it was the companies that were raising the alarm about log shortages in the near future. These documents are available on both my website and the government’s. Continue reading

Preventing Future Tragedies

Another worker lost his life in a sawmill yesterday. There will be yet another investigation, more recriminations and second guessing, but nothing will change the fact that another human being went to work and won’t ever come home.

I spent some time with the workers from the Lakeland Mill last night and stood with them as they silently reflected on this most recent tragedy at another BC sawmill. I had some explaining to do regarding comments ascribed to me in the media about the future of the Lakeland Mill that had made some of the workers angry.

During the evening I was able to speak with workers who were in the mill the night it exploded, men who rescued their co-workers, stripped off their burned clothes, and gave what first aid and comfort they could while they waited for the ambulances to arrive.

It was a sober reminder that while we argue about what could and should have been done, who’s to blame, and what needs to be done now, there are people who will be both physically and emotionally scarred because the system of essentially self-regulated workplaces failed them.

For too long we’ve bought into the mantra that we can penny pinch on enforcement and replace standards and regulations with voluntary compliance and industry-led safety councils and still have the highest health and safety standards in our workplaces. We can’t and we don’t, as recent events have so tragically proved.

If we’re truly going to honour those who have lost their lives in this most recent and catastrophic round of workplace incidents, then we have to reassert the need for government regulations and standards and for stringent enforcement of those standards through unannounced inspections and more inspectors. Workers’ voices must be listened to in the design of safety systems and during the inspection and compliance process.

In short, government regulations and enforcement are the best tools we have to protect the public interest and improve the safety of workers. It’s time to halt deregulation and the pretense that industry can both maximize profits and protect workers (and the environment). To be clear, this is not an indictment of industry, or of the specific companies involved in these most recent incidents. It is an indictment of the ideology of self-regulation and minimalist government. In a profit-driven economy, government must play an active role in protecting the public interest through best practice regulations in order to prevent a race to the bottom that puts workers and the environment at risk.

Poisoned Relationships

This weekend I was provided with a letter that Taseko Mines President Russ Hallbauer sent to Federal Environment Minister Peter Kent last November. The letter was sent in advance of the new panel hearings into Taseko’s proposed Prosperity Project. Unfortunately, the letter clearly illustrates why the Tsilhqot’in (TNG) will fight, with every means available to them, Taseko’s right to the “Prosperity” ore body on their traditional territory. It also illustrates why some First Nations’ leaders are saying Prosperity is not only the wrong project, but the wrong company.

The letter asks Minister Kent, under threat of legal action by Taseko, to ensure that no First Nations person is put on the new review panel, to disallow any ceremonial activities during the panel hearings (drumming and prayers), to not allow children to demonstrate their concerns through plays, and to reject spirituality as a consideration in the mine proposal. The letter argues that emotional displays like drumming and children’s plays will, consciously or unconsciously, sway the panel in favour of the First Nations and against the “science” of Taseko’s case. Continue reading

Leaked Cabinet document reveals how far government was willing to go

When I was home during the Easter break I caught wind that the government was contemplating a “Burns Lake Recovery Act,” legislation designed to guarantee a log supply for Burns Lake to ensure Hampton Affiliates would rebuild the mill that burned down in January. Industry representatives told me that the path the government was contemplating was not one they were either interested in or happy about.

They were not interested because they felt the government was going too far in their thinking about lifting land use constraints in order to free up timber in the Lakes District. Rather than simply looking at relaxing things like Visual Quality Objectives (VQOs) or seral stage (mixed aged stands) that would not undermine the integrity of the non-timber values protected under land use plans, the government was willing to effectively negate the entire land use plan in the Lakes District. Continue reading

Three Years of Timber Supply Left?

In 2002, it became evident that the mountain pine beetle (MPB) epidemic hitting the central interior of BC was of an order of magnitude different than anything the province had experienced before and was likely going to wipe out BC’s interior lodgepole pine forest. A committee of Liberal MLAs called on their own premier to declare the epidemic an emergency and marshal provincial and federal resources to prepare communities for the inevitable crash in the annual allowable cut and the mill closures that would surely come as a result.

Ten years have passed and the provincial government still has no plans in place for the communities in the areas hardest hit by the pine beetle, as evidenced so dramatically in Burns Lake. The hodge-podge of politically motivated spending announcements in that community and the government’s scrambling to engineer a timber supply at the expense of other communities on Highway 16 reveals how much the Liberal government has mishandled, mismanaged, and misrepresented the MPB epidemic. Continue reading

Fallacies of “One Project, One Review” Logic

The federal government’s rationale for streamlining the environmental review process is based on fallacious arguments about the certainty that’s needed for investors and about the state of Canada’s regulatory regime.

In B.C., the real certainty that’s needed is a resolution to the question of ownership. No tinkering with the environmental review process will make B.C. attractive to investors as long as First Nations’ rights and title issues remain unresolved. Until this fundamental question of ownership of the resources is addressed, B.C. will never be the safe haven for investors the BC Liberals claim it to be. Projects that manage to make it through an environmental review in a timely manner and with a positive outcome will still be subjected to protests and court challenges if the rights and title to the resources remain contested. Continue reading

Political Firestorm

The feeding frenzy in the hallways of the BC Legislature continued today as the media scrummed any Liberal MLA who was silly enough to pause and face the cameras and give a reaction to the defection of one of their colleagues to the BC Conservatives.

In part, this was a result of the BC NDP using the Member from Abbotsford South as a poster child for a large portion of Question Period today. If some of the BC Liberals had laser vision, John Van Dongen would have been burnt to a crisp — and I’d likely have been collateral damage as we now sit beside each other! Continue reading

Thoughts on Leaving the Wild West

My head was spinning as I drove away from Dawson Creek, and on the long drive back to Wells, where  I was meeting friends for the weekend, I had time to try and process what I had experienced over the past week.

Vicki Huntington and I are committed to making an effort to address the public policy gaps we saw during our brief investigation of the oil and gas industry; it’s our intent to provide suggestions and options for the government to consider. But, without being presumptive of what Vicki and I focus on and recommend, there are some top of mind reflections I have from our week in the Wild West. Continue reading

Day 4: The Good, The Bad & The Ugly

Today Vicki and I toured a waste site north of Ft. St. John; a place where the toxic byproducts of the oil and gas business are disposed of in engineered landfills or deep underground. The site was a stark reminder that oil and gas extraction permanently toxifies the Earth’s soil and water resources.

Let’s face it, resource extraction is an ugly business: clearcuts, wellpads, pipelines, mine pits, roads and seismic lines fragmenting the land base, horrible smells, toxic leaks and spills. It’s intellectually dishonest to suggest or to choose to believe that we can extract the Earth’s resources to feed our consumptive habits with no or minimal “ecological footprint.” The human “footprint” is huge, destructive, and has, throughout our history, resulted in resource depletion and ecological collapse. Continue reading

Day 3 in the “Wild West”

Once again the “Wild West” catch phrase was used by the area residents we met today. In a meeting at the Farmer’s Advocate’s Office in Dawson Creek a concerned farmer told us “it ain’t the ‘wild west’ it’s the ‘wild, wild, wild west.’” He was from Farmington, an area that Vicki and I had toured in the afternoon where we witnessed first hand the impacts of the recently accelerated development of shale gas.

It was crystal clear from what we saw in Farmington that there is NO planning and coordination function anywhere in the system. Pipeline right of ways crisscrossed the landscape and signs bearing the skull and cross bones warning of sour gas were everywhere. Country roads had been turned into industrial freeways, complete with jake brake and speed warning signs. The school was surrounded with gas wells. And, all this activity represents only the very beginning of shale gas development in this area. Continue reading